Saturday, October 2, 2010
Autopsy specimen
There are 2 sides to this story, and a New York judge has just ruled that the dispute can be settled in court.
From the perspective of the New York City Medical Examiner's Office:
A 17-year-old African-American male living in Staten Island was killed by crushing injuries in an auto accident on 1 Jan 2005. Consent for an autopsy was obtained from the victim's father. The postmortem was performed and the remains were released to the funeral home the same day. The medical examiner's office is accused of failure to inform the Shipleys that they had removed and retained Jesse's brain, violating their right of sepulcher. The retention of the organ came to light during a visit to the morgue by the classmates of the decedent's sister. "In what can only be described as a surreal coincidence, the label on the jar indicated that the brain was that of Jesse Shipley, a circumstance which evoked strong emotional reactions from some of the students who were present." The office had retained the brain to perform further neuropathologic examination, which was scheduled shortly after the class field trip. Although this was 2 months after Jesse Shipley's death, the analysis was pending the accumulation of 6 brains to warrant the trip of an examiner from the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner to Staten Island.
From the perspective of the Shipley family:
Beloved son and brother Jesse, a Port Richmond High School student, lost his life in a car crash on January 9th, 2005. Jesse's father gave permission for an autopsy. Three days after his death, Jesse's funeral was held. When classmates of Jesse's sister Shannon - who had also been injured in the accident - went on a field trip to the Richmond County Mortuary 2 months later, they noticed a human brain suspended in formaldehyde. They were stunned and sickened to see that the label on the jar read "Jesse Shipley." News of the macabre discovery soon spread to Shannon Shipley, who told her parents. The Shipleys petitioned for the return of their son's brain, held a 2nd funeral, and sued the city and the M.E.'s office for not returning all of Jesse's remains.
While the M.E.'s office has the statutory authority to retain organs for further examination and testing, they are obligated to release them to the next of kin for burial once the legitimate purposes for retaining them have been fulfilled, concluded a judicial panel, allowing the lawsuit to go forward. In question is whether the defendants had properly advised the family when the body was released that one or more organs had been removed for further study. "This requirement, hardly onerous in nature, strikes an appropriate balance between the fulfillment of the legitimate scientific and investigative duties of the Medical Examiner's Office and the recognition of the long-established rights of next of kin to receive and provide final repose to the remains of their loved ones," said the judge in his ruling. But the family also wonders whether the brain had been lawfully retained for scientific purposes in light of the fact that the cause of death was known. The court denied the Shipleys' motion to sue for additional damages arising from what they alleged was the brain's public display. The specimen was in a cabinet with other organs and had not been mishandled.
1st image) A set from the "Preserved Specimens and Specimen Jars" collection that can be rented from B.J. Winslow Prop Rentals and Fabrication in Los Angeles, 2nd image) Mr. and Mrs. Andre Shipley, 3rd image) Jesse Shipley.
Labels:
autopsy,
weird news
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
- "Silence of the Lambs" (1)
- Abraham Lincoln (10)
- accident (60)
- advertisements (1)
- Afghan girl (1)
- Agatha Christie (2)
- aging (20)
- Aimee Mullins (1)
- airplane graveyard (1)
- albino (9)
- Albrecht Dürer (1)
- Alfred Butts (2)
- Alfred Eisenstaedt (1)
- Alfred Hitchcock (1)
- Alfred Russel Wallace (3)
- amputation (36)
- Amy Wynn Pastor (1)
- anatomical waxes (3)
- anatomy (96)
- anatomy theatre (3)
- ancient Egypt (19)
- Andrée Expedition (1)
- Andrew Jackson (1)
- androgyny (1)
- Angkor Wat (1)
- animals (659)
- animals. weird news (2)
- Anne Frank (1)
- anthropodermic binding (3)
- Anthropodermic books (1)
- Antiques Roadshow (1)
- Archaeology (110)
- architecture (71)
- Arcosanti (1)
- Art (51)
- Art Aufderheide (1)
- Arthur Fiedler (1)
- assassination (6)
- Astronomy (5)
- atavism (1)
- Athanasius Kircher (1)
- Auctions (8)
- Augustus Saint-Gaudens (1)
- Aung San Suu Kyi (1)
- aurora (1)
- Auschwitz (1)
- automata (2)
- autopsy (8)
- avian abduction (1)
- balloon festival (2)
- beetle brooches (1)
- Ben Carson (1)
- Betty White (1)
- Bill Bass (2)
- bird mask (1)
- blizzard (1)
- blood donation (1)
- Bob Waldmire (2)
- body (2)
- Body Farm (2)
- body modification (1)
- bodysnatching (3)
- BodyWorlds (1)
- bog bodies (4)
- bookmobile (1)
- books (20)
- Brian Dettmer (1)
- burial customs (9)
- burqa (1)
- button collecting (1)
- cabinet of curiosities (5)
- cabinet of curiositiesth (1)
- cannibalism (15)
- capital punishment (1)
- casket (9)
- catacombs (4)
- cause of death (143)
- Causes of death (22)
- caves (13)
- cemeteries (36)
- census (1)
- Chang and Eng Bunker (1)
- Charles Altamont Doyle (1)
- Charles Darwin (4)
- Charles Dickens (2)
- Charles Jones (1)
- Charles Tripp (1)
- chastity belt (1)
- chimney sweeps (1)
- Christo (1)
- chunnel (1)
- circadian rhythm (1)
- Civil War (10)
- clocks (1)
- coffee (1)
- collections (1)
- conjoined twins (10)
- corpse (24)
- corpse flower (3)
- Corpses (2)
- corsets (1)
- Countess Elizabeth Báthory (1)
- cremation (11)
- Crittercam (2)
- crucifixion (1)
- crypt (1)
- custom of the sea (1)
- Damien Hirst (1)
- Dante Gabriel Rossetti (1)
- David Teniers the Younger (1)
- Dead Man Walking (1)
- death dates (1)
- death mask (4)
- Death of Innocents (1)
- death penalty (2)
- death row (1)
- death studies (1)
- deaths (8)
- decapitation (12)
- Decay (3)
- Declaration of Independence (1)
- dendrochronology (1)
- dermestid beetles (2)
- Día de los Muertos (1)
- dining (1)
- dioramas (1)
- Dirty Jobs (2)
- disaster (29)
- Disasters (1)
- disease (2)
- dissection (23)
- Donner Party (1)
- doppelgänger (1)
- double womb (1)
- dowsing (1)
- Dr. Seuss (3)
- Dracula (3)
- dreams (3)
- Duke of Hamilton (1)
- Dutch wooden shoes (1)
- Eartha Kitt (1)
- earthquake (2)
- Edgar Allan Poe (4)
- Edward Bulwer-Lytton (1)
- Edward Gorey (1)
- elevators (2)
- Eli Bowen (1)
- Elizabeth Heyert (1)
- Elizabeth I (1)
- Elizabeth Siddal (1)
- Elvis Presley (2)
- embalming (19)
- embryo (1)
- Emmett Kelly (1)
- Emmett Till (1)
- Emperor Nero (1)
- Engineering (14)
- Environment (25)
- Ernest Shackleton (3)
- Ernst Haeckel (1)
- eunuchs (1)
- Eva Perón (1)
- Evelyn Waugh (1)
- excavation (60)
- execution (13)
- exhibit (1)
- exhumation (11)
- expedition (15)
- Exploration (11)
- explosions (1)
- extinction (14)
- eyewitness (1)
- F. Gonzalez-Crussi (1)
- Fabergé eggs (1)
- facial reconstruction (3)
- Fashion (7)
- feral children (5)
- fiddlehead ferns (1)
- field trips (1)
- figurehead (1)
- fingerprints (1)
- fireworks (2)
- Flannery O'Connor (1)
- Florence Nightingale (1)
- folklore (49)
- Food (25)
- Fortean Times (1)
- fossil fuels (1)
- fossils (105)
- fractals (1)
- Frank Buckland (1)
- Franklin Expedition (1)
- Frederik Ruysch (2)
- funeral (11)
- funeral caissons (2)
- funeral food (1)
- funeral museums (5)
- funeral services (4)
- funicular (1)
- garden (23)
- Gardening (10)
- genealogy (4)
- genetics (1)
- geography (3)
- Geology (20)
- George Higham (2)
- Georgia O'Keeffe (1)
- ghosts (1)
- Giant's Causeway (1)
- gibbeting (1)
- Giovanni Belzoni (1)
- Giuseppe Arcimboldo (1)
- gladiator (1)
- golem (1)
- Govard Bidloo (1)
- graduate school (1)
- grave (9)
- gravesites (14)
- gravestone (9)
- Gretchen Worden (1)
- guest posts (2)
- Gunther von Hagens (3)
- hair (3)
- hair jewelry (1)
- Halloween (17)
- hanging (2)
- Hannah Kersey (1)
- harps (1)
- Harry Houdini (1)
- hearse (4)
- Hearst Castle (1)
- helicopters (1)
- helium (1)
- hermits (2)
- Hindenburg (1)
- Hippolyte Bayard (1)
- History (3)
- hoarding (10)
- Honoré Fragonard (1)
- horror stories (1)
- hot air balloons (2)
- Hottentot Venus (1)
- Howard Carter (1)
- human marvels (47)
- incorruptibles (1)
- Insects (28)
- institutionalization (1)
- intelligence (1)
- inventions (3)
- Iwo Jima Memorial (1)
- James Taylor (3)
- Jan Svankmeyer (2)
- Janet Mann (1)
- Jasmine Day (1)
- Jay Walker (1)
- Jayne Mansfield (1)
- Jeffrey Silverthorne (1)
- Jeremy Bentham (2)
- Jill Tracy (1)
- Jimi Hendrix (1)
- Jody Arlington (4)
- Joel-Peter Witkin (1)
- Johannes Vermeer (1)
- john butler trio (2)
- John F. Kennedy (1)
- John Horwood (1)
- John James Audubon (1)
- Jorge Lopez (1)
- Joseph Cornell (1)
- Julia Pastrana (1)
- Kathryn Myers (1)
- King Edward VII (1)
- kosher and halal (1)
- Kublai Khan (1)
- Kumbh mela (1)
- Lachrymatories (1)
- Lake Tahoe (1)
- Leonardo da Vinci (7)
- Lewis Hine (2)
- Lincoln (1)
- Linda Hunt (1)
- Literature (2)
- Lord's Prayer on the head of a pin (1)
- lying in state (1)
- M.C. Escher (2)
- Madeleine Albright (1)
- Maisenbacher House (1)
- Maj.-Gen. Daniel Sickles (1)
- Makpal Abdrazakova (1)
- Mammoths (4)
- Man on Wire (2)
- marginalia (1)
- marionettes (1)
- Mariska Hargitay (1)
- Mark Twain (1)
- Marlboro Man (1)
- martyrdom (1)
- Mary Fields (1)
- Mary Scott Huff (1)
- Maurice Sendak (3)
- Max Ehrmann (1)
- May Savidge (1)
- Medical (1)
- Medicine (20)
- memento mori (2)
- memorial (5)
- Meret Oppenheim (1)
- Millie-Christine (1)
- minerals (1)
- mirrors (1)
- mobility scooter (1)
- Möbius strip (1)
- Momento Mori (1)
- morgue (5)
- mourning (4)
- mourning jewelry (2)
- mummies (101)
- Munchkins (1)
- murder (34)
- museum (31)
- Museums (27)
- Music (10)
- musical instruments (9)
- Mütter Museum (6)
- Myrtle Corbin (1)
- Nadar (1)
- Napoleon Bonaparte (1)
- Nat Love (1)
- National Library of Medicine (1)
- National Museum of Health and Medicine (2)
- necrophilia (1)
- Neil deGrasse Tyson (1)
- Neil Gaiman (1)
- Noah's Ark (1)
- northern lights (1)
- Nutshell Studies of Unexplained Death (1)
- obituaries (7)
- Occam's razor (1)
- oil spill (2)
- Onfim's drawings (1)
- optogram (1)
- organ donation (1)
- origami (1)
- ossuaries (3)
- P.T. Barnum (2)
- paintings (9)
- Paleontology (3)
- pathology (1)
- Patricia Lay-Dorsey (1)
- Pedro Ara (1)
- Pere Lachaise Cemetery (3)
- petrified wood (1)
- Philippe Petit (2)
- photography (138)
- phrenology (1)
- pica (2)
- pirates (3)
- plague (3)
- Plants (2)
- plastination (6)
- Plum Island (1)
- Poaching (1)
- poison (6)
- Polly Morgan (1)
- popemobile (1)
- population (1)
- Posthumous (2)
- potter's field (1)
- premature burial (1)
- preservation (2)
- presidents (1)
- prison (4)
- private islands (3)
- progeria (1)
- Progress report (1)
- promession (1)
- public dissection (7)
- Queen Victoria (1)
- R. Buckminster Fuller (1)
- Rainbow portrait (1)
- Rainn Wilson (1)
- relics (9)
- Religion (1)
- Remy Charlip (1)
- Rene Magritte (2)
- rescue (1)
- Richard Parker (1)
- Roald Dahl (2)
- Robert Capa (1)
- Robert Rauschenberg (1)
- Roger Williams (1)
- Rosamond Purcell (2)
- Rube Goldberg (1)
- Ruth Richardson (1)
- Saartjie Baartman (1)
- Sally Mann (1)
- Salvador Dali (2)
- samuel pickering (2)
- Samuel Taylor Coleridge (1)
- Santa Baby (1)
- Sarah Bernhardt (1)
- sarcophagus (1)
- scullery maids (1)
- Shakers (1)
- shanghaiing (1)
- Sharbat Gula (1)
- shipwreck (4)
- Shirley Jackson (1)
- shrunken heads (1)
- sideshow (4)
- Sigmund Freud (1)
- Sister Helen Prejean (1)
- Six Feet Under (2)
- skeletons (74)
- skulls (20)
- sleepwalking (1)
- Space (8)
- space chimp (3)
- spider (1)
- St. Louis MO (1)
- Stand by Me (1)
- Star Wars (1)
- Statue of Liberty (1)
- steampunk (1)
- Stephanie Millward (1)
- Stephen Hawking (1)
- submarine (1)
- suicide (16)
- suitcases (1)
- superstition (1)
- surgery (1)
- survival (6)
- sword swallowing (1)
- symbols (2)
- synchronicity (2)
- tarot (1)
- tattoo (10)
- taxidermy (30)
- Technology (16)
- Teddy Roosevelt (1)
- Temple Grandin (2)
- teratology (1)
- The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1)
- The Loved One (1)
- Theodore Roosevelt (1)
- Thomas Edison (1)
- Tim Hawkinson (1)
- Timbuktu (1)
- time capsule (7)
- Timothy Dexter (1)
- Titanic (4)
- Tocci Twins (1)
- torture (1)
- transplantation (4)
- transportation (1)
- tree ring dating (1)
- trees (11)
- trepanation (1)
- trephination (1)
- tsantsas (1)
- turkey pardon (1)
- Typhoid Mary (1)
- urban decay (1)
- vandalism (2)
- vanitas (1)
- vanity paintings (1)
- Victor Noir (1)
- Viking ship burial (1)
- Visible Human Project (1)
- vivisection (3)
- Walt Disney (1)
- Walter de Maria (1)
- war (44)
- Ware Hall House (1)
- weather (40)
- weird news (698)
- While They Slept (1)
- William Archibald Spooner (1)
- William Burke (1)
- William Cowper (1)
- William Kidd (1)
- William Wegman (1)
- wingspan (1)
- Winston Churchill (1)
- Woolly mammoth (6)
- Yellowstone (2)
- zeppelin (1)
- zombies (2)
- Zoos (15)
No comments:
Post a Comment
You may add your comments here.